We've already done trauma-informed training
Why supporting survivors of sexual and childhood trauma in maternity care needs more than general trauma-informed training
I hear this often, and it is a fair thing to say. Many midwives, maternity support workers and doulas have completed trauma-informed care training in the last few years. It is good training, and it matters.
But after 14 years of supporting women through pregnancy and birth, I have come to believe that sexual and childhood trauma in maternity care needs something more specific. Not a different philosophy. A different level of detail. Here is why.
What general trauma-informed care gives us
In the UK, most trauma-informed training builds on the government's working definition of trauma-informed practice, published by the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities in 2022 for everyone working in health and care.
It asks practitioners to realise that trauma can affect individuals, groups and communities, to recognise its signs, symptoms and impact, and to prevent re-traumatisation. It rests on six principles: safety, trustworthiness, choice, collaboration, empowerment and cultural consideration.
These principles are the foundation of everything I teach. But they are designed for any trauma, in any setting: a housing office, an emergency department, a GP surgery. By design, they work at the level of principles, not procedures.
And in maternity care, for survivors of sexual abuse, the procedures are exactly where the harm can happen.
When the care itself resembles the harm
In most of healthcare, trauma can be triggered by care. In maternity care, for survivors of sexual abuse, the care itself can resemble the harm.
Think about what a vaginal examination involves. Someone in authority, touching the most intimate part of her body, internally, while she lies on her back, partly undressed, often in pain, with limited ability to stop it. For a woman who was sexually abused, almost every element of that sentence can echo what was done to her before.
The same parts of the body. The same positions. The same imbalance of power. Sometimes even the same words: "relax", "good girl", "it will be over soon".
Researchers in the UK have a name for this. In a study of women who were sexually abused in childhood, Montgomery, Pope and Rogers (2015) described the re-enactment of abuse in maternity care. Women experienced it through intimate procedures, but also through pain, loss of control, encounters with strangers and unexpected triggers.
One finding stays with me more than any other. Intimate procedures were not necessarily a problem in themselves. How they were carried out was what mattered.
That is the whole case for this work. We cannot stop examining women. We can change how we do it.
What sexual and childhood trauma bring
General training gives us the principles. Sexual and childhood trauma change what those principles mean at the bedside.
General trauma-informed training | Survivors of sexual and childhood trauma | |
Touch | Be aware that touch may be difficult | Care touches the same parts of the body as the harm |
Consent | Good practice | The core clinical skill: its absence was the harm |
Calm | Distress is the warning sign | Calm may be freeze, and compliance may not be consent |
Language | Communicate kindly | Some kind words are the words used during abuse |
Memory | She knows what happened | It may have begun before she had words for it |
Disclosure | Respond to known trauma | Make care safe without ever knowing |
Compliance was taught. A child who is abused often survives by being good, quiet and cooperative. As an adult, that can look like the ideal patient. Staff describe her as easy. She may in fact be frozen, unable to say no.
It often began before she had words. In the Truth Project run by the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse, 79% of participants said they were aged 11 or under when the abuse began (IICSA, 2022). A young child has no language for what is happening. The trauma may be held in the body rather than in a story. She may not know why she is panicking, and she may not call it abuse.
The harm often came from someone trusted. When the person who caused harm was meant to care for her, care and authority themselves can become signals of danger. A midwife is both.
Most will never tell you. In the same Truth Project, two thirds told no one at the time (IICSA Truth Project Dashboard, 2016 to 2021). So the skill is not responding to a history we know. It is making care safe without ever knowing.
Trauma-informed care, applied where it matters most
This is not a different model. Every principle in the UK definition still applies. What survivors need is those principles translated into the specific triggers, words, responses and procedures of maternity care.
It is not birth trauma training either. Birth trauma training looks at trauma caused by the birth. This work looks at the trauma a woman brings into her pregnancy and birth, and at how our care can stop it repeating. The two overlap, but they are not the same.
I also want to be honest. Montgomery and colleagues found that even sensitive care did not always prevent these experiences. Some triggers are personal and unpredictable. The aim is not perfection. It is to make re-enactment less likely, and to know what to do when it happens.
And because most survivors will never disclose, everything this work asks of us helps every woman. Explaining before touch. Asking for consent as we go, not once. Protecting privacy. Offering real choices. Pausing when a woman goes quiet.
We will rarely know who she is. So we care for everyone as though she might be there.
Michaela Kalusová is a doula, holds a Masters in Psychology, and is the founder of the SAFER Birth Project, which offers trauma-informed training for maternity professionals: saferbirthproject.co.uk
Sources
Office for Health Improvement and Disparities (2022). Working definition of trauma-informed practice. GOV.UK.
Montgomery, E., Pope, C. and Rogers, J. (2015). The re-enactment of childhood sexual abuse in maternity care: a qualitative study. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth, 15, 194.
Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (2022). Final Report, D.4: "I was just a child".
Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (2022). Truth Project Dashboard: June 2016 to October 2021.



Comments