top of page

Heard the first time: Black women, sexual trauma and maternity care

Oct 7
6 min read

What happens when a history of trauma meets a system that already struggles to listen, and what every maternity professional can do about it.


October is Black History Month in the UK, and this year's theme is Honouring Our Communities. In maternity care, I think that asks two things of us. To honour the Black midwives and nurses who helped build our care. And to make sure the Black women in that care are safe within it, including the ones who have never told anyone what happened to them. Most of this article is about the second. But I want to begin with the first.


Honouring the hands that held us


In 1964, Daphne Steele became the first Black matron in the NHS. A Guyanese nurse and midwife, she took charge of St Winifred's maternity hospital in Ilkley, West Yorkshire. Sixty years later, in 2024, she became the first person honoured with an official blue plaque outside London. Her son put it simply: "My mother saw herself as a nurse and midwife."

Behind her name are thousands of Black midwives, nurses and maternity support workers whose names are on no plaque. Many came from the Caribbean and Africa to train and work in the NHS, and many of their daughters and granddaughters are midwives today. Much of the care we are proud of was built by their hands.


Honouring them means more than remembering. It means making the care they built safe for the women who walk through our doors now, and for Black survivors above all.


For years I have written about the survivor nobody sees: the woman who goes very still during an examination, whose silence is read as consent, whose notes say "tolerated well."


But there is a question I have not asked loudly enough. What happens when that woman is also a Black woman, walking into a maternity system that has already shown, again and again, that it does not listen to Black women the way it listens to others?


This article is my attempt to answer that honestly, using what the evidence shows and being clear about where it runs out.


Two histories in one room


Every survivor brings her own history into the birth room. Many Black women bring a second one too: the experience, personal and shared, of being doubted, stereotyped or dismissed by the very services meant to care for them.


The national picture is stark. The latest MBRRACE-UK report, published in September, found that Black women were nearly three times more likely than white women to die during pregnancy or up to six weeks after birth. Maternal suicide remains the leading cause of direct death between six weeks and one year after birth.


Birthrights' national inquiry was clear about the cause: systemic racism, not broken bodies. Black, brown and mixed-ethnicity women described being ignored, stereotyped and receiving lower quality care.


Black women's own accounts say the same. Five X More surveyed 845 Black and Black mixed-heritage women who were pregnant in the UK between 2021 and 2025. Among their findings:


  • 28% reported experiencing discrimination.

  • 23% did not receive the pain relief they asked for, and of those, 40% were given no explanation.

  • Of the women who raised concerns during labour or birth, almost half felt their concerns were not properly addressed.

  • 71% did not know they could ask for a debrief after birth.

  • Women described procedures carried out without their permission, and the "strong Black woman" stereotype leading to their pain being downplayed or overlooked.


Now place a survivor of sexual trauma inside those numbers.


When being dismissed lands twice


For a survivor, the most harmful moments in maternity care are rarely the dramatic ones. They are ordinary ones: being touched without warning, being told rather than asked, being held still, having "stop" ignored, not being believed.


Those are exactly the moments that Black women describe most often.


For a Black survivor, being dismissed can echo both her own trauma and racism. When her pain is doubted, it can feel like every time she was not believed. When a procedure happens without her agreement, her body may recognise it before her mind can catch up. When she speaks up and is labelled "difficult" or "aggressive," she learns once again that her voice is a risk.


The stereotype of the strong Black woman does particular damage here. Survivors often cope by going quiet, by complying, by disappearing somewhere inside themselves. If staff already expect a Black woman to "cope," her freeze is even easier to miss. And if she resists, the same stereotype can turn her protection into a label.


Survivors describe powerlessness, betrayal and humiliation as the heart of a traumatic birth. For Black survivors, racism can deepen every one of them.


What the numbers can and cannot tell us


I want to be careful here, because this subject deserves accuracy, not assumption.


We know sexual violence is common. The Office for National Statistics estimates that around one in four women in England and Wales have experienced sexual assault since the age of 16. ONS data also show that Black and Mixed ethnicity adults were more likely than White, Asian or Other ethnic groups to have experienced sexual assault in the past year, although for rape or assault by penetration specifically, no significant difference between ethnic groups was found.


What we do not have is good UK data on Black survivors' experiences of maternity care itself. That gap is part of the story. When women are not asked, not heard, or do not feel safe enough to disclose, they do not appear in the evidence either. And Black women may have extra reasons not to disclose: fear of being judged, fear of social services, or simply the experience of not being believed before.


So no one should read this as "Black women are more traumatised." What I am saying is simpler: a system that struggles to listen to Black women and a system that struggles to recognise trauma will fail Black survivors in both ways at once.


What changes the room


The good news is that what helps a Black survivor is not complicated, and it helps every woman.


Believe her the first time. Treat what she tells you, about her pain, her body or her fear, as clinical information. Do not wait for it to be repeated, escalated or proven.


Make consent ongoing. Before any touch or procedure, explain, ask, and wait for her answer. "Is now a good time, or do you need a moment?" costs a few seconds and gives back the one thing trauma took away: choice.


Hear the music behind the words. Going quiet, needing to know every step, refusing, or saying "stop" may be her way of keeping herself safe. What gets labelled "difficult" is often a message about what she needs.


Check your own shortcuts. Notice when "she's coping well" or "she's being aggressive" comes to mind. Ask whether you would read the same behaviour the same way in a white woman.


Make debriefs and complaints visible. Tell every woman, without waiting to be asked, that she can have a debrief and how to raise a concern. Seven in ten Black women in the Five X More survey did not know a debrief was available.


Refer well. Know your local perinatal mental health services, and know the Black-led organisations doing this work, such as The Motherhood Group, Five X More, Black Mothers Matter and the Motivational Mums Club.


Joy is part of safety too


It would be wrong to finish with harm alone. Black mothers deserve more than survival. They deserve births where they feel safe, respected, believed and joyful.


For a survivor, a birth where she was heard can do more than avoid harm. It can be the first time her body felt safe in a clinical room. That is not a small thing. It is the kind of care we should be offering every woman, and it is the care Black survivors have waited longest for.

Listening is not a soft skill. It is safety.



If anything in this article is close to home, support is available. Rape Crisis England and Wales runs a free 24-hour support line on 0808 500 2222. Samaritans can be reached free on 116 123, any time.


Sources

MBRRACE-UK. Saving Lives, Improving Mothers' Care, September 2026 (data 2022 to 24), as summarised by the Maternal Mental Health Alliance.

Birthrights. Systemic racism, not broken bodies: An inquiry into racial injustice and human rights in UK maternity care, 2022.

Five X More. Black Maternity Experiences Report, 2025.

Office for National Statistics. Sexual offences victim characteristics, England and Wales: year ending March 2020 (ethnicity data 2018 to 2020) and year ending March 2025.

Garratt, L. Survivors of Childhood Sexual Abuse and Midwifery Practice: CSA, Birth and Powerlessness. Radcliffe, 2011.

Maternal Mental Health Alliance. Black maternal mental health in the UK.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page